|Full name||Tobias Butler|
|First appeared||Case #43 The Showstopper|
Tobias is 36-years-old secret agent with shaved hair and blue eyes.He wears a tuxedo and a blue rose.
Tobias was spoken to after team found his DNA on Joe's briefcase.He said that Joe was his good friend and that he trusted him.
Tobias was spoken to again after team found restraining order Joe ordered for Tobias.Tobias claimed that Joe thought he was only a trouble and dangerous person.
The killer was revealed to be him.Tobias said that he is working as a hitman and that his client paid him into killing Joe for unknown reasons.In courtroom,Judge Eva Rose tried to convince Tobias into telling her who paid him to kill Joe,but he wouldn't say anything.Eva sentenced him to life in prison with no chance of parole.