After the murder of George Aker, the player discovered that he was supposed to meet Natalia at Miss Blue Coasts' yacht party, since he was her client. Natalia admitted that she was a prostitute and that she was glad that George was dead, since she had no respect for a man in his fifties willing to pay a nineteen-year-old girl to have sex with her. She was interrogated a second time when they found out that George was apparently in love with her and that they had met more than once before. She admitted that he would buy her a lot of things to make her interested in him, but she never cared about him and wouldn't keep any of his gifts. She was not one of the main suspects in the case.
Natalia became a murder suspect again after Amanda Sotomayor was killed right before the finale of Miss Blue Coasts, with her being one of the top 3 contestants. The police found a bloodstained earring with Natalia's fingerprints on it at the crime scene, and she said that it was her own earring and her own blood as well, since she had lost it after a physical altercation with Amanda. The reason for their fight was that Amanda got angry at her and started calling her a "cheap hooker". Later, the team discovered that Natalia had also sued Amanda for a sexual offense, which made the player and Nora MacMillon interrogate her one more time, since she had not told them about that detail. She said that Amanda had tried to humiliate her but did not want to get into the specifics of what had gone down. She was not a major suspect in this case either.