Davy Malstaire
Have an image of this character?
Then please upload it!
Biographical information
Full name Davy Malstaire
Gender Male
Status Deceased
Death 2018
Cause of death Stab wounds to the torso
Personal information
Nationality United States of America American
Residence Aurelia, Italy
Profession(s) Pirate
Family Yvonne Malstaire (sister)
Partner(s) Jeannine Hughes (fiancée)
Rhonda Hilton (ex-girlfriend; incarcerated)
Affiliation(s) The Black Mercy
Game information
Appears in Criminal Case
First appeared Case #7: Arrr Me Killer

Davy Malstaire was the victim in Arrr Me Killer (Case #7 of Aurelia).


Calm down, partner. This section is soon to be added.

Murder Details

Calm down, partner. This section is soon to be added.

Killer and Motives

The killer would turn out to be castaway Rhonda Hilton.

The castaway confessed to the crime and explained that Davy deserved to die as he was the one who had left her stranded on a secluded island in the first place. She explained that she and Davy had been in a romantic relationship but she suspected him of cheating on her. Soon, she discovered that Davy was also dating Jeannine, the mayor’s assistant. When Rhonda confronted Davy, he knocked her out and stranded her on the island so he could propose to Jeannine without Rhonda’s disturbance. Eventually, she was rescued from the island by a boat of fisherman and then she decided to kill Davy by hunting him down and stabbing him to death with a switchblade. During her trial, Judge Rodriguez told Rhonda that nothing excused murder and sentenced her to ten years in prison for her murderous actions.

Case Appearances

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.