Maddie and the player headed to the Orpha farm to investigate Roger Orpha's whereabouts following his kidnapping on Arthur's instruction. When they arrived at the farm, however, they heard shouting from a nearby barn and went to investigate. There, they found the body of farmhand Elihu Harrington, mauled to death by a pack of dogs. They swiftly sent the body to Dick before questioning cowboy Brock Rumwell, trainee journalist Constance Parthena, and superstitious woman Ophelia Moire. They were then confronted by a woman clutching a shotgun, threatening to shoot them for arresting her granddaughter.